Ice for Thermal Energy Storage


Ice has long been used for space comfort conditioning. In the early nineteenth century, ice was placed in air ducts to cool and dehumidify warm air blown by fans. I recently saw such a system that was still in use in the Hungarian Parliament building after more than a century of service. The ice in that system was harvested from Lake Balaton in the winter and placed in the air ducts when needed for summer cooling.

Since harvesting and year-round ice storage is not common these days, mechanical refrigeration is used to make ice, often at night when electric rates are lower. This ice is stored, and when cooling is needed water is circulated through the ice storage area and then distributed at about 34F (1.7C) to provide space cooling, although lower temperatures can be used with appropriate fluids.

Ice thermal storage has two potential advantages. In addition to the use of off-peak ice making, an ice storage system can reduce chilled water flow requirements by half. A traditional chilled water system using 44F (6.7C) supply and 54F (12.2C) return will require 2.4 gallons per minute (gpm) of chilled water for each ton-hour of refrigeration. An ice storage system can supply chilled water at 34F (1.7C), reducing the required chilled water flow to 1.2 gpm.


Ice Storage Around the World

The following table, provided by W. D. McCloskey of Baltimore Air Coil, shows examples of ice storage used for district cooling around the world.

Location Ice Storage Capacity Serves
Cosmo Square, Osaka, Japan.

Joint venture by Kansai Electric Power and Osaka Gas

29,300 ton-hours

103,000 kWh

Ice storage part of central plant serving six buildings in Nanko, Osaka, Japan, including the World Trade Center and the Asia Trade Center. Steam and hot water also provided.
USF&G Office Complex

Baltimore, Maryland

5500 ton-hours

19,360 kWh

Cools six office buildings in the headquarters complex for the USF&G Insurance Corporation. Uses ammonia as refrigerant.
Chauffage Urbain Prodith

Lyon, France

8530 ton-hours

30,053 kWh

Cools 4.3 million sq ft (400,000 sq m) of office space in conjunction with traditional chilled water system.
Unicom Thermal Technologies

Chicago, Illinois

66,000 ton-hours

232,300 kWh

Serves commercial customers in Loop area of downtown Chicago. Plant located next to Palmer House Hotel.
Montgomery College

(2 systems)

Rockville & Germantown, Maryland

Each system:

2,440 ton-hours

8,590 kWh

Each system cools five classroom buildings. Uses ammonia as refrigerant. Rockville system to be expanded to serve 17 buildings.
San Antonio City Water Board

San Antonio, Texas

19,300 ton-hours

62,288 kWh

Serves 21 customers, including Alamodome. Built 1993.
University of Miami

Miami, Florida

3,660 ton-hours

12,883 kWh

Supplies chilled water to 13 campus buildings
Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory

Laurel, Maryland

8,400 ton-hours

29,568 kWh

Built in 1988. Cools four office/laboratory buildings.
Johns Hopkins University

Baltimore, Maryland

11,200 ton-hours

39,420 kWh

Cools main campus.
Homesavings of America

Irvindale, California

13,600 ton-hours

47,872 kWh

Serves five headquarter buildings of Homesavings of America.
Lee College

Baytown Texas

5,535 ton-hours

19,483 kWh

Part of a central district cooling system serving 30 buildings. Shifts 760 kW load to off peak for ice building.
Please send any additions or corrections to Morris A. Pierce.