
Energy Storage
General Description
Energy storage involves methods and apparatus used to store heating, cooling, or power. In
district energy applications these encompass a wide variety of applications, but all are designed
to be recharged on a cyclical basis (usually daily, occasionally seasonally) and fulfill one or more
of the following purposes:
- Increase system generation capacity
- Demand for heating, cooling, or power is seldom constant over time, and the excess
generation available during low demand periods can be used to charge the energy
storage apparatus in order to increase capacity during high demand periods. This
allows a smaller production unit to be installed (or to add capacity without purchasing
additional units) and results in a higher load factor on the units.
- Enable dispatch of cogeneration plants
- Combined heat and power, or cogeneration, plants are generally operated to meet the
demands of the connected thermal load, which often results in excess electric
generation during periods of low electric use. By incorporating thermal energy storage,
the plant need not be operated continuously and can be dispatched within some limits.
- Shift energy purchases to low cost periods
- This is the demand-side application of the first purpose listed, and allows an energy
consumer subject to time-of-day pricing to shift energy purchases from high cost to low
cost periods.
- Increase system reliability
- Any form of energy storage, from a small personal computer uninteruptable power
supply (UPS) to a large pumped storage project, will almost certainly increase system
reliability.
- Integration with other functions
- In applications where on-site water storage is needed for fire protection, it may be
feasible to incorporate thermal storage into a common storage tank. Likewise,
apparatus designed to solve power quality problems may be adaptable to energy storage
purposes as well.
A Short History of Energy Storage
The oldest form of energy storage involves harvesting ice from lakes and rivers, which was
stored in well insulated warehouses and sold or used throughout the year for almost everything
we use mechanical refrigeration for today, including preserving food, cooling drinks, and air
conditioning. The Hungarian Parliament Building in Budapest is still air conditioned with ice
harvested from Lake Balaton in the winter. Quite an impressive system, which I was able to visit
last summer.
Chemically-charged batteries became quite common in the mid-nineteenth century to provide
power for telegraphs, signal lighting, and other electrical apparatus. By the 1890s central
stations were providing both heating and lighting, and many did both. Electric systems were
almost all direct current (DC), so incorporating batteries was relatively easy. In 1896, Toledo
inventor Homer T. Yaryan installed a thermal storage tank at one of his low temperature hot
water district heating plants in that city to permit capturing excess heat when electric demand
was high. Other plants used steam storage tanks, which were not as successful for some reason.
Other forms of energy storage were used to power street cars in the 1890s, including compressed
air and high temperature hot water that was flashed into steam to run a steam engine. Electric
cars and trucks were quite common prior to World War I until gasoline-powered internal
combustion engines ran them off the road.
Energy storage has always been closely associated with solar installations, including both solar
heating and photovoltaic (PV) applications. Today you can find compressed air storage,
batteries, chilled and hot water storage, ice storage, and the occasional flywell in use, all
designed to meet one or more of the purposes listed above. Many utilities provide incentives for
energy storage applications, while time-of-day rates and stiff demand charges also entice
customers to consider these opportunities.
Applications
This material will take me some time to sort out and get on line, but in the meantime here is
some introductory material. The fundamental basic never-to-be-forgotten rule of energy
storage is to remember that it is part of a system, and whatever storage mechanism is used has be
properly engineered into that system.
Electric Power Storage
- There are some sites on the web with information on pumped storage facilities, which I
will track down and add here. I also know some people who have done compressed air
storage, and have some information on flywheels and other devices that might have
application in district energy applications. Lots of research in this area going on.
- Some examples of ice thermal storage systems are shown here.
Water Thermal Storage
- This is by far the most common form of thermal energy storage in use today. I will be
adding some information on hot water storage used with cogeneration plants, but for
now I have the following available:
- University of California - Irvine
- A short list of welded steel tank systems.
- Welded steel tank system vendors
- Walker CBI
- Caldwell Tank
- Pitt-DesMoines
- Wire-wound concrete tank vendors
- Reinforced concrete tanks (no vendors for these - each is designed and built to the specific
project requirements.)
- University of Iowa - 7,000 ton-hours, buried beneath a football practice field.
- Georgetown University - 2 million gallon tank underneath a parking garage.
- Arizona State University - 54,000 ton-hours, empty tank system, located beneath
athletic fields.
- Youngstown State University, 1 million gallon tank under parking garage.
- New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM.
- 3 M gallon, below parking lot on campus.
- Stratified storage, linear diffuser system.
- Over 10 yrs in operation (on-line since 1986)
- well documented and monitored (ref: "Chilled-Water Thermal Storage
System Performance Monitoring," Hensel et al., ASHRAE Transactions 1991,
V. 97, Pt 2.)
- will be happy to arrange a visit to the system. Chang sohn, U.S. Army CERL Tel:217-398-5424
FAX: 217-373-3430 e-mail: c-sohn@cecer.army.mil
- Stanford University (no details)
- Yale University, 3,000,000 gallons chilled water storage tank, buried under a
parking lot, tennis court and green space, in use since circa 1978. Contact: Dave Spalding, Sr. Mech. Eng., Yale University, dave.spalding@yale.EDU
- Trigen-Trenton has a 3 million gallon chilled water storage tank that has
been in service for approx. 5 years. The tank is partially above/below
grade and doubles as a helipad. Contact Mike Coleman at 609-396-7651, ext. 117.
- Ft. Huachuca, Arizona, 500,000 gallon stratified chilled water underground system installed around 1992.
- U.S. Naval Academy, system currently under design. Contact Shannon McDowell, smcdowel@novell.nadn.navy.MIL
- University of Cincinnati, 3 million gallon system currently under design.
Energy Storage Publications
District Energy Library
Last updated 2 June 2000